Skip to content

Apartments over retail

Mixed-use deal analysis

  • A mixed-use deal is two businesses in one building.
  • The apartments and the shop do not share a vacancy rate, and they should not share a rent.
  • They do share one NOI, one loan, and one verdict.

Two rolls, one plate

  • I keep the residential income and the commercial income apart until NOI.
  • Residential gross potential rent is units times monthly rent times 12.
  • Commercial gross potential rent is area times rent per square foot per year.
  • Each line has its own vacancy.
  • Other income is added once.
  • Operating expenses are taken once.

That is the whole trick, and it is easy to lose in a spreadsheet that grew a tab at a time. The engine holds both lines in one pro forma, then prices the NOI, sizes the loan, and writes the verdict from that same run.

Worked example

  • Cayuga Commons (Illustrative Case) in Ithaca, NY is the illustrative case the engine is locked to.
  • It is 24 apartments at $2,400.00 a month, vacancy 6.00%, and 4,200 square feet of retail at $38.00 per square foot per year, vacancy 8.00%.
  • The price is $8,500,000.
  • The hold is 7 years.
  • The exit cap is 6.50%.
  • Rent growth on this case is 3.00% a year.
  • Expense growth is 2.50%.
  • The loan is 65% of price at 6.25%.
  • Year 1 debt service is $408,220.50.
Cayuga Commons (Illustrative Case), Ithaca, NY. Engine output on the illustrative case.
Purchase price
$8,500,000
Year 1 NOI
$594,066.40
Going-in cap rate
6.99%
Project IRR
15.34%
Equity multiple
2.4351x
Minimum DSCR
1.46x
Verdict
PURSUE

Where this pass simplifies

  • Street retail under apartments often wants its own growth, its own vacancy path, and its own exit cap.
  • This model uses one rent growth rate and one exit cap for the whole building.
  • A named tenant roll is supported when the lease terms can be written in whole years.
  • A term the model cannot represent is not rounded into a nearby year.

Those limits are on the mixed-use methodology page and the model boundaries.

Frequently asked questions

How is mixed-use different from multifamily here?
  • Mixed-use keeps a residential line and a commercial line.
  • Each has its own vacancy.
  • They meet in one NOI, one loan, and one verdict.
What does the illustrative case show?
  • Cayuga Commons (Illustrative Case), Ithaca, NY.
  • 24 apartments and 4,200 square feet of retail.
  • Year 1 NOI is $594,066.40.
  • Project IRR is 15.34%.
  • The equity multiple is 2.4351x.
  • Minimum DSCR is 1.46x.
  • The verdict is PURSUE.
Can the shop and the apartments grow at different rates?
  • Not in this model.
  • They share one rent growth rate and one exit cap.
  • The mixed-use methodology page says where that is a simplification.
Is the worked example free?
  • Yes.
  • Cayuga Commons (Illustrative Case) opens with no sign-in.
  • Your own mixed-use deal is Underwrite Core, $49 per user per month, and the first 30 days are free.